Order Online | I Bake It That Way

Pickup, ASAP (in 2 days)

Double Layer Round Cakes
Whipped Cream Cakes
Sheet Cakes
Cake Pops
Cupcakes
Cookies
My New Section

Double Layer Round Cakes Whipped Cream Cakes Sheet Cakes Cake Pops Cupcakes Cookies My New Section

I Bake It That Way Menu CHRISTMAS Double Layer Round Cakes Whipped Cream Cakes Sheet Cakes Cake Pops Cupcakes Cookies My New Section

I Bake It That Way Menu

Cakes, Cupcakes, Cake Pops, Specialty Cakes, Sheet Cakes, Cinnamon Rolls & Cookies.

Double Layer Round Cakes
Whipped Cream Cakes
Sheet Cakes
Cake Pops
Cupcakes
Cookies
My New Section

Double Layer Round Cakes Whipped Cream Cakes Sheet Cakes Cake Pops Cupcakes Cookies My New Section

Double Layer Round Cakes

Double layer round cakes come in eight flavors and customization options. Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Red Velvet, Marble, Confetti, Lemon, Cherry. Sizes are are 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, and 16 inch round. *All Vanilla, Almond, or chocolate cakes are buttercream frosted. (Egg, dairy, gluten, soy, and nut free upon request.)

$35.0035.00 USD

Whipped Cream Cakes

Whipped cream cakes can be Gluten & Egg Free

Chocolate Decadence Whipped cream cake comes in two sizes, 6 , 8, 10,12, 14 inches. Can also be Gluten & Egg Free Options are available but are not standard.

Special

$48.0048.00 USD

Cookies & Cream Whipped Cream Cake can be Gluten & Egg Free and comes in two sizes, 6 & 8 inches.

Special

$45.0045.00 USD

Peanut Butter Whipped Cream Cake comes in two sizes, 6 & 8 inches. Can be Gluten & Egg Free upon request.

Special

$45.0045.00 USD

Salted Caramel Whipped Cream Cake comes in two sizes, 6 & 8 inches. Can also be egg, gluten, soy, and nut free.

Special

$45.0045.00 USD

chocolate decadence cupcakes by the dozen

$45.0045.00 USD

Sheet Cakes

Sheet cakes are single layer that come in quarter, half and full sizes. They can be variously decorated with animal drawings, flowers, balloons and character drawings. (Egg, dairy, gluten, soy, nut upon request)

Sheet Cakes are made to order. You may call to place this order or pick from sizes and flavor/allergy request *For special toppings, Please, call: (309) 945-5870

$40.0040.00 USD

Cake Pops

Cake Pops are perfect for large and small parties. Cake pops are made to order by the dozen. Custom amounts can be made, call for a special orders.

Flavors are per doze Red Velvet, Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Confetti.

Special

$22.0022.00 USD

Call To Make A Special Order (309) 945-5870 $24 and up per dozen. Options of: shape, painted, fondant, multicolor

Special

$24.0024.00 USD

Class orders are 30 count cakepops, 1 flavor, 1 color, and sprinkles. For multi colors or flavors please order per dozen

$42.0042.00 USD

Cupcakes

Vanilla, Chocolate, and sprinkled cupcakes.

1 Dozen Frosted Cupcakes *gluten free options available.

$20.0020.00 USD

Floral cupcakes can be multiple flowers and colors *Gluten Free Options Available

Special

$36.0036.00 USD

Mini Cupcakes. 30 pack. Flavors are single flavor Vanilla, Chocolate & Confetti. Includes single color frosting, Chocolate or Vanilla sprinkles inlcuded

$25.0025.00 USD

Call for quote: (309) 945-5870

Special

$0.000.00 USD

Cookies

2 Inch Cookies, 1 Color, Rounded Shape, individually wrapped. Chocolate Chip, Snicker Doodle, Peanut Butter.

Decorated Royal Iced Cookies by the Dozen sizes/intricate details vary floral would be considered intricate or anything painted with golds/silvers/ colors

$12.0012.00 USD

Cookies that are 2-inch, allergen-free come in Buttercream Frosted Sugar Cookie, or Royal Iced Cookies. School orders consist of 30 cookies all same shape, same color, sprinkles included upon request. School orders do NOT included decorated details. Decorated cookies with details will be by the dozen cost.

Special

$35.0035.00 USD

My New Section

pick from Cake and cupcake boxes or floral cupcake arrangements

This box includes a double layer cake, 5 cupcakes design in different florals. All boxes will have Happy Mothers day topper included. custom flavors such as chocoloate, vanilla, cherry, red velvet, carrot, lemon, strawberry, or confetti available. Ganache or swiss meringue buttercream extra

$45.0045.00 USD

This box comes with a 4 inch double layer cake and 5 cupcakes decorated in intricate flowers with sweet dried noodle floral pieces added for an extra touch. All butterflies used are edible as well as 24 K gold luster dust peals. flavor decision upon request

$43.0043.00 USD Sold Out

Sold Out

This Bento box comes with 4 inch double layer cake and 5 cupcakes simple design. There are no intricate floral details, colors can be requested. Butterflies are not edible.

$31.0031.00 USD Sold Out

Sold Out

This bento box is for the chocolate lovers. 4 inch double layer chocolate cake filled with chocolate buttercream and ganache. Chocolate ganache drip and shavings top the cake and cupcakes.

$36.0036.00 USD

All vanilla almond frosted buttercream 4 inch cake and cupcakes. The "wedding cake flavor" This all white simplistic cake set is great for a small wedding gathering, bride and groom gift. can be done without almond flavoring upon request

$40.0040.00 USD

bento box with 4 inch double layer cake and 5 cupcakes. colors and designs can be personalized to fit your requests. This basic set does not include intricate flower details.

$45.0045.00 USD

CHRISTMAS

Different options for Christmas

24 count Advent Cookie Calendar
cocoa bomb advent calendar
12 count cookie box
DECORATE YOUR OWN COOKIE BOX
CHRISTMAS PLATTERS
TEACHER BOX

24 count Advent Cookie Calendar cocoa bomb advent calendar 12 count cookie box DECORATE YOUR OWN COOKIE BOX CHRISTMAS PLATTERS TEACHER BOX

24 count Advent Cookie Calendar

All individual cookies will in packaged in their own compartment. Open each day to reveal new designs. boxes will be ready for pick up at my Geneseo I bake it that way bakery and cafe location on 11/29-12-1 2025. Should you need an earlier pick up date please let me know. boxes are limited quantity.

24 individually wrapped cookies each with a different design for each day leading up to Christmas. All cookies stay fresh in heat sealed bags.

$45.0045.00 USD

cocoa bomb advent calendar

12 different cocoa bomb designs and mixed flavors. Each day is something new whether its a design or flavor or both. designs will vary and be themed around Christmas.

cocoa bombs range in designs, flavors, and include special surprised such as edible glitter, marshmallows, chocolate spoons

$50.0050.00 USD

12 count cookie box

12 cookies individually wrapped, each day a different design. portions of the proceeds will benefit the Henry County Humane society and the Geneseo Food pantry depending on which box you buy!

12 DAY ALLERGY FRIENDLY BOX. GLUTEN, EGG, DAIRY FREE COOKIES WITH DIFFERENT DESIGNS. ONLY AVAILABLE IN THE 12 COUNT

$35.0035.00 USD

12 DIFFERENT DAYS OF COOKIES each cookie is differently designed for cats and dogs. Every cookie will be individually wrapped. date for pick up will be up to you starting December 1st. pre orders open til November 20th.

$30.0030.00 USD

12 days of cookies individually wrapped and sealed. portions of each box will be going to the food pantry. pick up available anytime starting December 1st.

$30.0030.00 USD

DECORATE YOUR OWN COOKIE BOX

Popular every season. DIY cookie box, every cookie, sprinkle and frosting supplied. You just decorate and enjoy. pick from royal icing or buttercream icing. Pick up starting 12/1/2025-12/24/25

12 cookies sprinkles 3 frostings

$24.0024.00 USD

12 cookies royal icing in 3 colors sprinkles

$22.0022.00 USD

12 cookies 3 frostings sprinkles all cookies and frosting and sprinkles- egg, dairy, gluten free all products nut free for non or allergy free items

$25.0025.00 USD

2 cookies to decorate with frosting and sprinkles 1 paint your own cookie

$10.0010.00 USD

CHRISTMAS PLATTERS

Different sizes available includes a mix of items: chocolate covered pretzels decorated cookies cakepops buckeyes pb ritz crackers with chocolate pb cookies chocolate chip cookies almond sprtiz mini cake pieces brownies

a mix of items from cookies, cakepops, chocolate covered pretzels, fudge, chocolate dipped items, pb cookies, chocolate chip cookies, oreo balls, brownies, buckeyes

$25.0025.00 USD

TEACHER BOX

PICK FROM DIFFERENT LOCATIONS LARGE COOKIE BOXED WITH CHRISTMAS PAPER AND COLORS AND A LOCAL $5 GIFT CARD TO LOCAL BUSINESSES

LARGE COOKIE BOXED WITH $5 GIFTCARD EVERY BOX WILL BE CHRISTMAS THEMED WITH RIBBONS AND BOWS

$0.000.00 USD